essays

It's Time for an Anti-Pornography Crusade

A national reform movement is needed to restore sexual order against the poison of pornography.

The Rape of Proserpina by Gian Lorenzo Bernini, Galleria Borghese, Rome

Cornell University is my alma mater. I spent four years there in a scholarship house known widely as a redoubt of nerds. As it happened, Telluride House had as its neighbor one of the most raucous fraternities on campus – a juxtaposition not without occasional levity, including when the brothers banded together outdoors and chanted, “Hey Telluride! E equals mc squared!” in our direction.

One Saturday night, as I was studying with a friend and distracted by noise from one of the frat’s epic parties, I suggested that we go over to see what these fabled soirees were like. He was skeptical, but the booming speakers were making study impossible, so he indulged me and off we went. Within two minutes of entering, as he left to get drinks, I was accosted by a tall, plastered brother in possession of what he thought was a winning proposal: if he could guess my weight within five pounds, I should go upstairs with him.

I laughed in his face, amused both by his ethanol-fueled chutzpah and by his swaying in the air above me like a mighty oak about to be felled. I motioned to my friend and we left the place, never to return. And that was the only thought I gave the episode until years later, when I was reading Tom Wolfe’s I Am Charlotte Simmons. A slew of memoirs of Greek life resulted in a column for TCT, urging Christian boys against joining fraternities.

The lesson learned on that far-off Ithaca night – that frat parties are no place for an unescorted young woman – might seem obvious. But that is exactly the pregnant point: not anymore.

Two years ago, at another Cornell fraternity, a young woman would make a different choice, and the resulting sordid tale would come to ricochet around the world. And though the details may be disputed in court from now until kingdom come, one fact is clear: she did not see it as ridiculous to acquiesce in what some smashed young men were up to. At least in the beginning, she saw acquiescence as her preferred choice.

What has changed between then and now? This brings us to the answer that’s gone missing in the commentary exploding everywhere over Cornell’s “Jane Doe.”

In December 2008, thanks in part to forward-looking philanthropist Sean Fieler, a first-of-its-kind conference on “The Social Costs of Pornography” was held at the Witherspoon Institute in Princeton, N.J. That conference had a major impact, including on my own thinking. It resulted in two critical books, also the first of their kind, summarizing evidence from doctors, therapists, neuroscientists, and other experts.

That evidence pointed to a truth that overrules today’s idolization of sexual autonomy: Pornography is poison. It alters brains, kills romance, and leads to intense loneliness. It creates addicts and destroys families. The empirical record has been well-documented since that landmark conference, and thereafter.

The data are in. What should we do about them? Here are thoughts I shared with a conference of women organized to discuss “A Better Way Forward” just last month:

If I could reduce years of meditating on this subject to one single action memo aimed at bettering the human condition, it would read like this. We need to re-stigmatize pornography. We – meaning not only those of us present, but also people across the West – need to understand that pornography today is like tobacco was yesterday: ubiquitous and toxic and in need of social reform. It is the enemy of romance. It licenses perversion. And pornography is also a major factor in today’s cratering rates of marriage and babies.

Those are the sad facts about a porn-drenched culture. And they call for a radical response:

We need something like a movement and manifesto Against the Acceptance of Pornography. It should include secular as well as religious people, and as many of the walking wounded as can be rallied – as well as the heads of faithful Christian universities and colleges, and celebrities, and therapists, and anyone else committed enough to sign on.

If anyone today doubts how important such a reform movement is to the restoration of a healthy culture, look no further than the Cornell story that has been front-page news since those words were spoken.

At its center is a female student accusing several fraternity members of rape. But to read the barbaric details is to understand something lost in the lurid retellings. These students – all of them – are so polluted by pornography that they are literally not in their right minds. Even without the drugs and alcohol that also saturate this horrifying picture, these young souls have been twisted already by a substance less obvious, but just as impairing. And they are mere representatives of many millions of young people like them.

In the spirit of snatching good from evil, therefore, the story of Jane Doe is one more proof that we need a national movement against pornography, along the lines of Mothers Against Drunk Driving. In fact, it should be a foundational proof – the final demonstration, in all its nauseating fullness, that catalyzes mere rhetoric into transformative action. And while such a movement is essential, it should also be only the beginning.

We need therapists who can deprogram kids like these. We need society at large to understand that internet pornography is a cult. And the crippling of that cult by any means necessary is a critical step – in fact, the most critical step – toward the restoration of a sexual order grounded in sanity, not lunacy.

Above all, we need someone to lead that movement. It is my hope that reiterating this message in every forum possible will someday touch the heart of that future leader, who will become to this reform movement what Florence Nightingale was to the nursing profession; what Dorothea Dix became to the reform of institutions for the mentally ill.

If there is a single prayer to send up from the putrid mess above Cayuga’s waters, imploring Heaven for that future leader is it.

This column is adapted from a speech given to the Napa Institute in New York City on October 14, 2026. It first appeared in The Catholic Thing on October 17, 2026.

Read the full essay